Mmcp.market

Head to head

Tkach Security vs Protect

Same numbers we show everywhere else, lined up. Ratings come from users, the grade comes from our scanner, adoption comes from public registries.

Tkach Securityio.github.ECD5A/tkach-security
B
No reviews yet

Fail-closed MCP adapter for untrusted model output over a local Tkach runtime.

Full listing
Protectcom.scopeblind/protect-mcp
C
No reviews yet

Fail-closed Cedar policy gate + Ed25519 signed receipts for agent tool calls. Denies on any error.

Full listing

The short version

Neither has been reviewed yet, so the comparison rests on the scan and the public usage numbers. The safety scan favours Tkach Security (73/100 against 57). Protect has noticeably more public adoption.

 Tkach SecurityProtect
User ratingNo reviews yetNo reviews yet
Safety gradeB73/100C57/100
AdoptionNewGrowing
GitHub stars19
Downloads / week–1.6k
Runs whereYour machine (local)Your machine (local)
Gateway-readyNoNo
Tools—12
Write actions—5
Price per callFreeFree
LicenceApache-2.0MIT
Last release2026-09-192026-09-17
CategoryAI and agentsAI and agents

Other comparisons

Tkach Security vs MockserverTkach Security vs PDFTkach Security vs Agent CommsTkach Security vs Pm Claude SkillsTkach Security vs HOL GuardAll AI and agents servers