Head to head
gedfire vs Semiotic
Same numbers we show everywhere else, lined up. Ratings come from users, the grade comes from our scanner, adoption comes from public registries.
No reviews yet
GEDCOM CLI and MCP server for AI-assisted family-history research with reviewable changesets.
Full listing
No reviews yet
Verified React chart generation: select, validate, repair, render, and inspect charts through MCP.
Full listingThe short version
Neither has been reviewed yet, so the comparison rests on the scan and the public usage numbers. Both score close on the safety scan (88 and 82 out of 100). Semiotic is hosted and callable through the gateway; gedfire runs on your own machine. Semiotic has noticeably more public adoption.
| gedfire | Semiotic | |
|---|---|---|
| User rating | No reviews yet | No reviews yet |
| Safety grade | A88/100 | B82/100 |
| Adoption | New | Widely used |
| GitHub stars | 1 | 2.7k |
| Downloads / week | – | 5.8k |
| Runs where | Your machine (local) | Hosted (remote) |
| Gateway-ready | No | Yes |
| Tools | — | 5 |
| Write actions | — | 1 |
| Price per call | Free | Free |
| Licence | MIT | Apache-2.0 |
| Last release | 2026-09-15 | 2026-09-19 |
| Category | Everything else | Everything else |